Company Logo

Amanda's Bakery

Verified by BOTW
Contact
Company Logo

About Amanda's Bakery

We offer custom cakes, cookies, cupcakes and any other dessert for your birthday, anniversary or other special event.

From the Amanda's Bakery website:
We offer custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and more. Everything is fresh, from scratch, and made to order!

Location & Directions for Amanda's Bakery

list-map
2525 Mermaid Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793
Get Directions

Services Amanda's Bakery Offers

Bakeries, Amanda's Bakery

  • Cake Maker
  • Cookies
  • Cupcakes
4.8 Out of 5.0

Reviews For Amanda's Bakery

Reviews for this business have been aggregated from multiple sources.

Based on 50 Reviews

Add Review
Lindsey Beakes
Review source: Google Lindsey Beakes Tuesday, May 25th 2021
Amanda went above and beyond for my Mom's 60th birthday cake! It was not only better than I could have imagined in person, but it was also delicious! She was a pleasure to work with throughout the process and can't wait to have another event I can use her for!
Report
Barbara anne
Review source: Google Barbara anne Sunday, May 23rd 2021
The baby shower cake I ordered came out absolutely beautiful! I described the look I wanted along with some pictures and the cake I envisioned was created. Many guests commented on how beautiful it was but the best part was how moist and delicious it was. This was my first time getting a cake from here but I can’t wait to try some of the cakes I saw while I was in the bakery.
Report
Joseph Mayer
Review source: Google Joseph Mayer Tuesday, May 18th 2021
Joseph Mayer opted not to leave a text review of Amanda's Bakery
Report
Joe Favaro
Review source: Google Joe Favaro Monday, May 10th 2021
I went there to get my daughter's cake and walked out with a few items telling me to buy more
Report
Cindy Dibartolo
Review source: Google Cindy Dibartolo Wednesday, May 5th 2021
Ordered a cake for my daughter's Bridal Shower, it came out beautiful and was a show stopper! Thank you for creating such a beautiful cake!
Report
Gen V
Review source: Google Gen V Monday, April 26th 2021
Came in Sat., waited 15 mins to be helped. Three people behind counter, only one person was waiting on Customers. Ordered/paid 2 small cakes ($43.) w/ Happy Birthday msgs. Told there was no special Order, only what was already baked, finished, in Cases. Settled for Cannoli Cake & Red Velvet. Asked when they were baked, told Friday. Tried to call when I got home, to ask if Red Velvet was Cocoa flavored (it wasn't (:-
Report
Robin Ramlakan
Review source: Google Robin Ramlakan Monday, April 12th 2021
Awesome cakes
Report
Marco Chavez
Review source: Google Marco Chavez Thursday, April 8th 2021
I visited this place on a whim after seeing it featured in the local news.

Amanda's makes the best rainbow cookies I've ever had in my life. I also got a pecan tart and a raspberry/almond tart, both of which were terrific as well. Will definitely be going back!
Report
Marcelin Pechin
Review source: Google Marcelin Pechin Sunday, March 28th 2021
High quality bakery. I pass several bakeri
es on my way there to get donuts.
Report
Toby Mullen
Review source: Google Toby Mullen Monday, March 22nd 2021
Great staff.amada I think her name is is awesome
Report
Rate us and Write a Review