Company Logo

Amanda's Bakery

Verified by BOTW
Company Logo

About Amanda's Bakery

We offer custom cakes, cookies, cupcakes and any other dessert for your birthday, anniversary or other special event.

From the Amanda's Bakery website:
We offer custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and more. Everything is fresh, from scratch, and made to order!

Location & Directions for Amanda's Bakery

2525 Mermaid Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793
Get Directions

Services Amanda's Bakery Offers

Bakeries, Amanda's Bakery

  • Cake Maker
  • Cookies
  • Cupcakes
4.8 Out of 5.0

Reviews For Amanda's Bakery

Reviews for this business have been aggregated from multiple sources.

Based on 50 Reviews

Add Review
Amandas Bakery Co.
Review source: Google Amandas Bakery Co. Sunday, November 20th 2022
Amandas Bakery Co. opted not to leave a text review of Amanda's Bakery
Glittering Farmer
Review source: Google Glittering Farmer Saturday, November 19th 2022
Staff works diligently that's for sure! Each cake I saw being picked up looked amazing. I was there for breakfast baked goods and a coffee though. Everything I tried was really yummy! I'll return and try more.
Danielle Adames
Review source: Google Danielle Adames Wednesday, October 19th 2022
This is such a cute little bakery in the heart of Bay Shore! I found it through google because I was looking for a good bakery and Amanda's Bakery had a 4.8/5, raving reviews, and beautiful photos so I knew I needed to try it. It is on main street so the parking in front is a little limited but there is a very convenient parking lot in the back along with side street parking. The atmosphere is adorable and is very inviting for a cup of joe or splitting your favorite pastry! My cousin and I got traditional cheesecake, 2 cakes pops, and a smores bite (I believe is what it is called). The cake pops were great because they were not overly sweet! The smores bite was absolutely delicious and definitely my second favorite. However, the cheesecake was the fan favorite! Even my mom started sneaking in bites because we could not stop talking about how great it was! I will definitely be coming back for more! 10/10 recommend!
Hazel Urban
Review source: Google Hazel Urban Thursday, October 6th 2022
Googled local bakerys for my husbands birthday cake. I couldn't be happier. I wound up ordering a blueberry pie, apple pie and key lime pie also.
Almost all was gone.
Did a beautiful job on the bday cake
Definitely would recomend.
Birthday was a 40th birthday Hoedown.
Samantha Nola
Review source: Google Samantha Nola Tuesday, October 4th 2022
I recently had two great experiences with Amanda's Bakery. I had a dozen cookies made, and a 70th birthday cake for my mom. The ordering process was easy and seamless, and the staff were extremely friendly and nice when I went to pick up my orders. They brought my vision to life with both the cookies and the cake, not to mention how great both tasted. My mom absolutely was in love with her cake, and she said it made her whole birthday. I cannot thank Amanda's Bakery enough for their attention to detail, customer service and over all great experience!
Rj VanDermark
Review source: Google Rj VanDermark Sunday, October 2nd 2022
Nice cozy store, Friendly reserved staff. Fresh Bakery goodies known for Petite servings style pastry. Interesting changing asorted items.
Jessica Rooney
Review source: Google Jessica Rooney Monday, August 22nd 2022
Ordered a paw patrol birthday cake for my daughter. It was delicious And absolutely beautiful. Highly recommend.
Kate Pentecoste
Review source: Google Kate Pentecoste Tuesday, August 16th 2022
I worked with Amanda’s bakery to create a Taco Bell themed birthday cake for my husband’s surprise 30th birthday. They were extremely quick to respond and easy to work with. The cake came out PERFECTLY! Not only was the outside so on point to what I was thinking, the cake and filling were beyond delicious (funfetti cake with cookies and cream filling). The cake surpassed my expectations and was the highlight of the day! I will be going back for future events.
Michele Lisio
Review source: Google Michele Lisio Monday, August 8th 2022
Strawberry shortcake for my daughters shower was INCREDIBLE !!!! We are ordering another cake for a party coming up in 2 weeks.
Diane Veiga
Review source: Google Diane Veiga Friday, July 29th 2022
I was "over the top" with my son's 25th birthday cake that Amanda made. I ordered my specialty "QUARTER" cake on line. I live in FLA but our immediate families all live in Long Island, NY. I wanted something to commemorate my son's milestone birthday. I read all the reviews and saw many great pics.of cakes posted and felt I picked the right bakery. The white cake with cannoli cream filling was super yummy. I received so many wonderful compliments. Thanks again, Amanda, for making such a MASTERPIECE!!
Rate us and Write a Review