10 Verified Reviews
Amanda's Bakery
2525 Mermaid Ave
Wantagh, NY 11793 US

About Amanda's Bakery

We offer custom cakes, cookies, cupcakes and any other dessert for your birthday, anniversary or other special event.

From the Amanda's Bakery website:
We offer custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and more. Everything is fresh, from scratch, and made to order!

Location & Directions

Get Directions

Services We Offer

Bakeries, Amanda's Bakery

  • Cake Maker
  • Cookies
  • Cupcakes

Business Details

No. of Employees No. of Locations Year Founded
N/A N/A 2020

Hours of Operation

Day Opens Closes
Sunday Open 24 hours!
Monday Open 24 hours!
Tuesday Open 24 hours!
Wednesday Open 24 hours!
Thursday Open 24 hours!
Friday Open 24 hours!
Saturday Open 24 hours!

Amanda's Bakery Reviews
  • Shannon O'Connor-Schlichter
    Shannon O'Connor-Schlichter

    Delicious and gorgeous cakes!! She did our wedding cake and my birthday cake a few weeks later, couldn't be happier!! Highly recommend!

  • sandy sanz
    sandy sanz

    Our wedding cake was so beautiful and not to mention so delicious thanks to Amanda's Bakery.

  • Pamela Schneller
    Pamela Schneller

    Great tasting, beautiful baked goods.

  • Teresa Daniele
    Teresa Daniele

    Teresa Daniele opted not to leave a text review of Amanda's Bakery

  • Cathie Guida
    Cathie Guida

    I ordered pink & blue swirled macaroons for a baby shower. They were a HIT!!! They were adorable and DELICIOUS!
    Thank you for quality cookies!

  • Carla Barnett
    Carla Barnett

    Linzer tart and fruit tart was amazing. Can't describe how delicious it was. Yes yes yes!

  • metal metal
    metal metal

    metal metal opted not to leave a text review of Amanda's Bakery

  • Lulu Ovalle
    Lulu Ovalle

    Amazing service !!! Thank you Amanda for creating an incredible and delicious cake with Army logo! Also thanking Kayla, Hannah and Natalie!!! You girls are the best!!!


  • PA MC
    PA MC

    DELISH! The best bakery around. They have a large selection of pastries, pies and cookies. And everything is not too sugary.

  • Jamie

    The cake was beautiful and so tasty. working with them was a pleasure ! INCREDIBLE!!!!!!

You May Also Consider
Raos Bakery
Raos Bakery

No Reviews Yet
King Cakes Online
King Cakes Online

No Reviews Yet
Gambino's Bakery
Gambino's Bakery

No Reviews Yet

Showcasing Businesses Since 1994

Best of the Web is an online platform connecting businesses and consumers backed by our team of editors. Our team verifies every business, product, and service before it gets listed in our directory and offers everyone the peace of mind that the products and services they’re looking for have been stamped as the Best of the Web.