Unclaimed Profile: This business may have incorrect or misleading details that have not been verified. If you are the business owner, click here to claim and correct this profile. Claim this Business
Phinney's Local Grocer
125 South Main Street
Newtown, CT 6470 US

About Phinney's Local Grocer

Phinney's is a local grocer based in Newtown Connecticut. We value trust and transparency, which is why we only partner with farms, producers, distributors, and importers who feel as strongly about keeping it real as we do. When you come to Phinney's, you're not only getting the best food products from in and around our area you're getting warm conversation with neighbors, and a chance to learn more about the part you play in your own local agricultural system.

Location & Directions

Get Directions
  • A Wide Range Of Produce And Grocery Items
  • Grocery Store

Business Details

No. of Employees No. of Locations Year Founded
3 N/A 2021


  • English

Hours of Operation

Hours of operation not available for this business.

Media Gallery

Phinney's Local Grocer Reviews
  • Katherine Mayhew
    Katherine Mayhew

    Hands down best independent grocery store I've ever been to. The selection, attention to detail, and hospitality of the owners are bar none. I only wish I lived nearby!

    Review source: Google
  • Sharon Cohen
    Sharon Cohen

    It is always great to see Jordan's high-school friends succeed, especially in culinary. How much better it is when stores are small and personable, the vegetables are fresh and the food is from local vendors. Glad to see this addition to Steve's Meat Market. Jordan says he'll come and say hi whenever he travels back from his personal place in LA.

    Review source: Google
  • Rebecca Hansen
    Rebecca Hansen

    A total local gem. While we don't make it up there as often as I'd like - every time we do it's magic. From locally sourced products to food you can't find anywhere else, this is one of my most favorite shops. The owners are amazing and so knowledgeable. Absolutely everything they sell has a story. You can't go wrong picking up some Rancho Gordo beans and local produce, or grabbing a jar of pistachio butter (worth every penny and a GREAT unique host gift). Phinneys is truly the perfect spot for any foodie.

    Review source: Google
  • Patricia Reinhardt
    Patricia Reinhardt

    What a great new addition to Newtown. A wonderful selection of fresh and unusual foods, personal service, and Steve and Gayle couldn't be more welcoming. We go every chance we get and also enjoy many of their Thursday night pre-ordered dinners.

    Re: What a great new addition ...
    Phinney's Local Grocer replied on Tuesday, August 31st 2021

    Thank you, Patricia! We love having you & David (& Sadie!) come by the store. Thanks for being so supportive of our business!

    Review source: Google
  • Geno Villafano
    Geno Villafano

    The best sandwiches around. And an amazing selection of unique high quality produce and products.

    Re: The best sandwiches aroun ...
    Phinney's Local Grocer replied on Monday, August 16th 2021

    Thanks, Geno!! Great to meet you and we are thrilled you enjoyed everything. See you again soon!

    Review source: Google
  • Becca

    Becca opted not to leave a text review of Phinney's Local Grocer

    Review source: Google
  • Ramon Puyane
    Ramon Puyane

    Ramon Puyane opted not to leave a text review of Phinney's Local Grocer

    Review source: Google
  • Stetson Hundgen
    Stetson Hundgen

    The definition of what a grocery store should be! Phinney's curates a selection of provisions like no other. Their local produce is always fresh and super high quality, and their dried & packaged goods have been blowing our minds good. It's so nice to go into a shop where the purveyor is carefully selecting awesome products and there isn't 1 million brands to choose from. Every single product I've purchased from Phinney's has been "wow delicious" - from the farm fresh milk & eggs to their chocolate bars and teas. I went in this weekend to purchase everything needed to make homemade pasta. Recognizing I was clearly a newbie in this arena, Stephen guided me through the process and we had a great time chatting about ideas. He even offered to let me borrow his pasta cookbook! The passion and love the Phinney's team puts into their work shines through in all that that they do. Can't wait to go back!!

    Re: The definition of what a ...
    Phinney's Local Grocer replied on Sunday, June 20th 2021

    Thank you, Stetson! Thrilled you enjoyed your experience and we look forward to welcoming you back again very soon!

    Review source: Google
  • Jeremy Sabath
    Jeremy Sabath

    Wonderful selection of local farm produce and high quality packaged goods. And the owners are incredibly friendly and will answer all of your questions!

    Re: Wonderful selection of lo ...
    Phinney's Local Grocer replied on Friday, May 21st 2021

    Thank you, Jeremy!! We look forward to seeing you in the store again soon!

    Review source: Google
  • M Daw
    M Daw

    Stopped in to grab something from the butcher and discovered Phinney's. Grabbed an order of appetizers and they were incredible. Can't wait to try the full dinner next week.

    Re: Stopped in to grab someth ...
    Phinney's Local Grocer replied on Wednesday, March 24th 2021

    Thank you! We are thrilled you enjoyed the sausage rolls and look forward to welcoming you back in the store very soon!

    Review source: Google
You May Also Consider

4920 N. Spring St.
Evansville, IN 47711 US

No Reviews Yet
View Listing
FastBreak Beverages
FastBreak Beverages

651 Academy Dr
Northbrook, IL 60062 US

No Reviews Yet
View Listing
Aisle One Kosher
Aisle One Kosher

217 Brook Ave
Passaic, NJ 07055 US

11 Verified Reviews
View Listing
Metropolitan Market
Metropolitan Market

1908 Queen Anne Ave N
Seattle, WA 98109 US

No Reviews Yet
View Listing

Showcasing Businesses Since 1994

Best of the Web is an online platform connecting businesses and consumers backed by our team of editors. Our team verifies every business, product, and service before it gets listed in our directory and offers everyone the peace of mind that the products and services they’re looking for have been stamped as the Best of the Web.