Company Logo

Maguire Subaru

Verified by BOTW
Contact
Company Logo

About Maguire Subaru

For a wide choice of new and used Subarus, visit Maguire Subaru in Ithaca. We also offer car loans, car repairs, auto servicing and car parts, all at great prices.

Location & Directions for Maguire Subaru

list-map
320 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850
Get Directions

Services Maguire Subaru Offers

Fleet sales
New vehicle sales
Pre-owned vehicle sales
Auto finance available
Car finder tool
Auto servicing
Parts sales
Bodyshop

  • Car Dealership
4.6 Out of 5.0

Reviews For Maguire Subaru

Reviews for this business have been aggregated from multiple sources.

Based on 10 Reviews

Add Review
mandostime P
Review source: Google mandostime P Wednesday, December 22nd 2021
mandostime P opted not to leave a text review of Maguire Subaru
Report
Natalie Katz
Review source: Google Natalie Katz Tuesday, December 21st 2021
Update: I dropped off my car Friday, picked it up Saturday (it was ready Friday but I had no one to drive me), filled it up with gas and went home. I didn't drive it Sunday or Monday, and now my car won't start. Clearly something Maguire did, this never happened before and now I need to have it towed back to them. If this wasn't a lease, I wouldn't bother with Maguire. I've always had a good experience at Hunt's across the street. Also, I'm not sure why Maguire thought it was appropriate to release personal information about my vehicle in their response to my post. And they said they would be happy to discuss the service, but in my original post, the price of their parts was the issue, not the service.
.
.
Service here seems normal, my only complaint is the price. They charged us around $440 just for new parts for a mirror I had broken (this price does not include installation or a paint job to match the car). When I told my husband he was outraged and cancelled the order and ordered the same exact original parts from Subaru for half the price ($220). So I would just say if you need parts for your car, better to order yourself and then have them installed rather than order the parts through Maguire.
Re: Update: I dropped off my ... Maguire Subaru replied on Tuesday, December 21st 2021

Natalie, Sorry to hear you had a poor experience with Maguire Subaru. If you would like to discuss this issue further about your 2019 Subaru Outback 3.6R Limited 4dr AWD SUV you can reach out to our General Manager, Bobby Hobbs, at [email protected].

Report
Denise Pitcher
Review source: Google Denise Pitcher Saturday, December 18th 2021
Denise Pitcher opted not to leave a text review of Maguire Subaru
Report
Elizabeth Bryan
Review source: Google Elizabeth Bryan Saturday, December 18th 2021
I have gotten my car inspected here twice and I have gotten several different maintenance/repairs done at Ithaca Subaru as well. The staff is ALWAYS kind and knowledgeable and willing to explain things to someone like me who knows very little about cars! 10/10 :)
Re: I have gotten my car insp ... Maguire Subaru replied on Tuesday, December 21st 2021

Elizabeth, Thank you so much for the positive review and very kind words. Thank you for choosing service your 2011 Subaru Impreza at Maguire Subaru in Ithaca, New York. We appreciate your business and we are always here for any of your automotive needs!

Report
Tp Mac
Review source: Google Tp Mac Saturday, December 18th 2021
Tp Mac opted not to leave a text review of Maguire Subaru
Report
Daniel Borin
Review source: Google Daniel Borin Saturday, December 18th 2021
Daniel Borin opted not to leave a text review of Maguire Subaru
Report
A Hall
Review source: Google A Hall Thursday, December 16th 2021
For my lease I worked with salesman Alex Hancharik and his manager Colby. This is my second lease through Subaru. Though the first lease went quite well (leased from a dealership in Oklahoma), Alex and Colby made this experience even smoother and more relaxed, which was much appreciated. They were hospital and communicated clearly. I will work with them again and recommend them highly. Bear in mind, Maguire is a business, so they're not going to negotiate on your behalf, but Alex and Colby were fair and transparent.
Re: For my lease I worked wit ... Maguire Subaru replied on Monday, December 20th 2021

Thanks so much for the review, A Hall! I am glad to hear Alex & Colby were able to help you out. We really appreciate your business. Thank you – Bobby Hobbs General Manager

Report
Crystal Hamilton
Review source: Google Crystal Hamilton Wednesday, December 15th 2021
Crystal Hamilton opted not to leave a text review of Maguire Subaru
Report
Lyle Cohen
Review source: Google Lyle Cohen Tuesday, December 14th 2021
Lyle Cohen opted not to leave a text review of Maguire Subaru
Report
Kathy Weinberg
Review source: Google Kathy Weinberg Tuesday, December 14th 2021
Our salesperson was helpful, answered all our questions, and did a good job. We had a comfortable experience.
Re: Our salesperson was helpf ... Maguire Subaru replied on Tuesday, December 14th 2021

Thanks so much for the review, Kathy Weinberg! We really appreciate your business. Thank you, Bobby Hobbs – General Manager

Report
Rate us and Write a Review

More About Maguire Subaru

Serving Ithaca and surrounding areas, Maguire Subaru has a reputation to be proud of. Our is a car dealership with an emphasis on old fashioned service and ethics - no pushy sales tactics here. Expect our professional staff to offer you sensible advice about the vehicle that's right for you, and to fully explain any and all finance options so that you know exactly what's what. As well as new Subarus, we also stock a wide range of quality preowned vehicles, each of which is guaranteed and warranties.

If you're looking for Subaru parts, our parts department can help. Alternatively, if you'd like us to work on your car, our on site service center is fully equipped to cater for everything from oil changes and minor maintenance to major repairs. Give us a call today of come and visit us to see the Maguire Subaru difference.