Gino's Pizza

I ordered a deep dish pizza, half white half reg. I asked for side of sauce as well. I was shocked they charged me for side of sauce..anywhere I've been and ordered white, w side of sauce I never got charged. Then delivery was late, pizza was Luke warm at best and then driver put 2 ltr bottle of Pepsi on box and crushed my pizza and sauce and it was all over inside of box. I emailed then and didn't even get a response....I sure do miss keith....

Re: I ordered a deep dish piz ... Gino's Pizza replied on Sunday, December 19th 2021

We are extremely sorry to hear about this and sorry to disappoint a customer. Please reach out to us at (631) 422-4600 as we want to hear your concerns and address them in the most suitable way. We look forward to hearing from you. Ask for Frank or Dave.

Pizza was amazing as usual. Service was on point, extremely amazing as it is everytime I stop in. Great place whether it's slices on the run or if you have time to dine in. Great job as usual!!!!!

Thought the chicken vodka slice was awesome. The rest looked good as well.

Re: Thought the chicken vodka ... Gino's Pizza replied on Monday, November 8th 2021

That is so amazing to hear, Rich! Thank you so much for taking the time to share your feedback with our team at New York Classic Pizza Joint - Gino's of Babylon. It's great to know that we continue to provide our customers with everything they need. Have a great day!

All I have to say is.....the artichoke slice. OMG its totally outrageous. And that "Babylon Special" slice......to die for. Staff is extremely friendly & courteous.

Re: All I have to say is..... ... Gino's Pizza replied on Monday, November 8th 2021

We're happy to hear you had an awesome time with us at New York Classic Pizza Joint - Gino's of Babylon! Thanks for sharing your experience. We hope you stop by and see us again soon.

I really like the food and service here. Their food is very good fresh and hot. I always have a good experience here. Stop by here if you are in town.

Love the spaghetti and meatballs and the people are very sweet I will be coming back again!

To start, the beautiful cashier greets with a smile and provides options of the days specials. Now to the pizza. I haven't been here since the change over from Ginos, but I should have. As you can see from the photos , I purchased a few but my favorite is the Babylon Special. Run,don't walk. Fantastic cream sauce, mushrooms *on point* along with dried tomatoes. I'll stop here but do know the rest of the slices were amazing in their own right. Go, Enjoy - Yum!

We ordered delivery yesterday and were happy with the fast turn around. We ordered a large Caesar salad with grilled chicken which was quite good. We also ordered a large Neapolitan plain pie with the everything spice crust. The flavors on the pizza were quite good as well. My only qualm or issue was they did not let the hot cheese on the pizza relax for a minute or settle before sending it out for delivery and the cheese moved around quite a bit and we weren't happy when we received it. You can see more clearly in the photo below.

The new owner is amazing! Best pizza and garlic knots around. We drive from a few towns away just for our favorites and they never disappoint!!

I've been to this spot a couple of times and thought I should write a review, because it quickly became the favorite pizza place in Babylon! This restaurant offers great prices, awesome food, and great costumer service. I always love dining in with the train going around the top of the store and great music! Definitely recommend for anyone looking for a good pizza spot in Babylon.

Re: I've been to this spot a ... Gino's Pizza replied on Tuesday, July 20th 2021

"Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us a 5-star review."